• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Naval Historical Society of Australia

Preserving Australia's Naval History

  • Events
  • Members Area
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Contact us
  • Show Search
  • 0 items
Hide Search
Menu
  • Home
  • Research
    • Where to start
      • Research – We can help!
      • Self help
      • Naval Service Records
      • Library
    • Resources
      • Articles
      • On This Day
      • Podcasts
      • Videos
      • Related Maritime websites
      • Downloads
    • Other
      • Newsletters: Call The Hands
      • Occasional Papers
      • Books
      • A Cook’s Tour
      • HMAS Shropshire
      • Book reviews
    • Close
  • Naval Heritage Sites
    • World Heritage Listings
      • Cockatoo Island
    • National Heritage Listings
      • HMAS Sydney II and the HSK Kormoran Shipwreck Sites
      • HMVS Cerberus
    • Commonwealth Heritage Listings
      • Garden Island NSW
      • HMAS Watson
      • HMAS Penguin
      • Spectacle Island Explosives Complex NSW
      • Chowder Bay Naval Facilities
      • Beecroft Peninsula NSW
      • Admiralty House, Garden and Fortifications
      • HMAS Cerberus
      • Naval Offices QLD
      • Garden Island WA
      • Royal Australian Naval College ACT
      • Royal Australian Naval Transmitting Station ACT
    • Close
  • Tours
    • Sub Base Platypus Tour (North Sydney)
    • Dockyard Heritage Tour
    • Heritage Tour of Northern End of Garden Island
    • Tour Bookings
    • Close
  • About us
    • About Us
      • What we do
      • Our People
      • Office Bearers
      • Become a volunteer
      • Our Goals and Strategy
    • Organisation
      • Victoria Chapter
      • WA Chapter
      • ACT Chapter
    • Close
  • Membership
  • Shop
  • Become a volunteer
  • Donate
You are here: Home / Archives for Australian Navy / HMAS Napier

HMAS Napier

Book Review: The Kellys

March 18, 2004

The Kellys – British J, K & N Class Destroyers of World War II
By Christopher Langtree
Published by Chatham Publishing, Kent, England
Distributed in Australia by Peribo
58 Beaumont Street, Mount Ku-Ring-Gai NSW 2080.
Hardcover 224 pages, RRP $110.00.

Reviewed by Vic Jeffery


One could be forgiven for thinking a book with the title, The Kelly’s, relates to the 19th Century Australian bushranger Ned Kelly and the infamous Kelly gang.

Not so; author and historian Christopher Langtree uses the name ‘Kelly’ as shorthand for all 24 members of the group which comprises three flotillas of eight each, of those magnificent British J, K and N class destroyers of World War Two.

The flotilla leader, HMS Kelly of course, was Lord Louis Mountbatten’s flagship and the most famous of the group. Of the three flotillas, the N-class flotilla was the only one to be entirely non-Royal Navy manned with five being Australian, two Dutch and one Polish-manned.

I believe they were perhaps the most handsome destroyers ever constructed. With their sleek low silhouettes, single raked funnel and a certain jauntiness about them, fast, heavily armed, innovative, and highly manoeuverable, they were a considerable advance in British destroyer design.

The five that served in the Royal Australian Navy during the War, Napier, Nizam, Nepal, Nestor and Norman were awarded 24 battle honours between them including Malta convoys, Atlantic, Bismarck 1941, Crete, Libya, Mediterranean, Indian Ocean, Pacific, Burma and Okinawa.

Amazingly, although the RAN’s N-class destroyers had a very busy war, only four men were lost to enemy action, in the Mediterranean when four stokers were killed when Nestor was near-missed by two heavy bombs which flooded the boiler rooms and caused the ship to lose power. A sister ship HMS Javelin took the stricken Nestor under tow, but as the tow parted twice and with more air attacks imminent at dawn, the daunting task of getting the crippled destroyer back to Alexandria 250 miles away became impossible. The decision was made to scuttle Nestor; her crew was taken off and she was sunk with a series of shallow set depth charges dropped nearby on 16 June 1941.

The second part of this book covers the entire service careers of the ships in detail, including the 12 lost on wartime service. It is indeed interesting to read the postwar careers of the four surviving RAN N-class ships after they reverted to Royal Navy control in 1945.

The five N-class in reserve, four former Australian and the former Polish Piorun (ex-Nerissa), came under close scrutiny for conversion to Type 16 frigates as part of the program to combat the new Soviet high-speed submarines that were entering service, which were faster than the wartime constructed anti-submarine frigates and sloops.

It was decided to produce a different type of conversion, the Type 18. These ships would have two primary purposes, firstly to protect convoys against submarine attack and secondly a seek-anddestroy role, in cooperation with aircraft if necessary.

History reveals that as the N-class destroyers were halfway through their hull lives, the project was not proceeded with. They remained in reserve until 1955 when the decision was made to dispose of them.

The 113 photos selected for this book are first class, with many never published previously.

The book fittingly opens with a doublepage spread of one of the finest destroyer shots of World War Two, a magnificent photo of HMS Kimberley at a vital moment of the Second Battle of Sirte on March 22, 1942. Kimberley is seen pounding through rough seas at 30 knots with guns elevated as the 14th Destroyer Flotilla turn to make a torpedo attack.

As well as the photographs, 24 technical and line drawings by John Lambert, 12 tables and eight appendices support this commendable book. John Roberts provides the known 17 colour camouflage schemes used by these ships.

These destroyers were certainly among the best destroyers of the Second World War. Ships based on the original design were still in service in the 1970s, long after these greyhounds of the sea had been scrapped.

Author Christopher Langtree is to be commended on his first effort in producing such an excellent reference book in an easy-to-read format, and also producing a work which fills a void in naval history.

 

Obituary: Ian Hunter McDonald RAN (1915-1996)

March 6, 1997

Captain IH McDonald
Captain IH McDonald

On 25 November 1996, 55 years to the day of the sinking of HMS Barham, in which he was serving and when 862 of his shipmates lost their lives, Captain Ian McDonald died at his home in Noosa, after a long illness. He is survived by his wife Nan, and two brothers, Rear Admiral Neil McDonald RAN (Rtd.), and Dr  Hugh McDonald, D.S.C. who also served in the RAN (1936-1946).

Admired and respected as `The Black Prince’ during his thirty year naval career, Ian served in six battle-ships, four cruisers and eight destroyers and was Captain of the first Australian Frigate Squadron in HMAS Shoalhaven, the first Australian ship into the Korean war zone. He later became Captain of the destroyers HMAS Tobruk and HMAS Anzac and retired from the Navy in 1958 from his last appointment as Director of Naval Intelligence.

He entered the RAN College at age 14, where he gained his colours for rugby, cricket, hockey, rowing and athletics and was twice the winner of the Governor-General’s Cup (1931-1932*). He became Chief Cadet Captain and on Passing Out he was first in all three groups of subjects, English-French-History, Engineering-Seamanship Navigation, and Mathematics-Physics-Chemistry, in addition to being awarded the Kind’s Medal**.

He became a midshipman in 1933, sub-lieutenant in 1936, Lieutenant in 1937, acting Lieutenant Commander in 1944 and Lieutenant-Commander in 1945. He sub-specialised in communications, and in 1939 was seconded to the Royal Navy as Flag-Lieutenant to the Flag Officer, Northern Patrol, before proceeding to the Mediterranean Fleet in 1940 as Flag-Lieutenant to Admiral Pridham-Wipple. He served with the Admiral until Barham was sunk. Miraculously, both survived and were rescued together.

On returning to Australia in 1942, he served in shore stations, including O.C. Signal School, Flinders Naval Depot, before returning to sea in 1944 as Flotilla Communications Officer in HMAS Napier in the British East Indies Fleet.

At the conclusion of hostilities with Japan, he was still in Napier which was then part of the British Pacific Fleet.

After WWII he spent two years on exchange duties in the Royal Navy, thereafter joining the light fleet carrier HMAS Sydney on commissioning. He was promoted to Commander, and later commanded HMA ships Shoalhaven, Tobruk and Anzac. He served as Executive Officer of HMAS Albatross before being promoted to Acting Captain and becoming Director of Naval Intelligence. He was granted the Honorary rank of Captain on retirement.

*Awarded annually for the best all-round sporting performance.

**Awarded annually to the cadet considered most deserving of the honour for gentlemanly bearing, character, good influence among his fellows, and officer-like qualities

The RAN’s Destroyers

March 11, 1991

Surely destroyers are the backbone of our Royal Australian Navy. Thirty-nine destroyers have served in the RAN since Foundation in 1911, from our first destroyers – HMA Ships PARRAMATTA (1), and YARRA (1), of only 700 tons, to our latest DDGs PERTH, HOBART and BRISBANE displacing over 4,500 tons.

River Class

HMAS Parramatta
HMAS Parramatta

Australia’s first destroyers were known as the River Class (I Class in the Royal Navy). The first two, PARRAMATTA and YARRA, were completely built in the UK during 1910/11, with WARREGO 1910/12, built in England, then disassembled and shipped to Australia to be rebuilt in Cockatoo Island Dockyard in NSW (for the ship building experience). The remaining four were completely built in Cockatoo Island Dockyard – WARREGO 1910/11/12, HUON (laid as DERWENT, but renamed HUON so as not to be confused with HMS DERWENT) 1913/15, TORRENS 1913/15 and SWAN 1915/16. They had a displacement of 700 tons, length 250ft, beam 24½ft and a 9ft draught. They carried one 4″ gun forward, 3x 12pdrs, 3×18″ torpedoes in tubes. Speed of 26/27 knots, with a complement of 66 officers and men. The cost of the UK built ships was £81,500, and the Australian built ships £160,000. (How times have changed.)

These ships served in the Mediterranean and the Pacific areas during World War I, and after the War, from 1919 in various duties, and for Naval Reserve training.

Gift Destroyers

In 1919 the RAN received six gift destroyers from the Royal Navy, the first was HMAS ANZAC (1), 1917 to 1933, a Marksman (Destroyer leader) Class destroyer of 1,660 tons, length 325ft, beam 31½ft, draught 12½ft, with three funnels. Her armament was 4×4″ guns, 2x12pdrs, 4×21″ torpedoes. She had a speed of 34 knots from her triple screws, with a complement of 122 officers and ratings. ANZAC transferred to the RAN, leaving Plymouth (England) in February 1920 and sailed to Sydney, arriving there on 29 April. There was little to do after the War (Great War), and she spent her time on the Australian east coast, though she visited New Guinea and New Britain in 1924, 1926 and 1930. But she remained the only destroyer kept through the depression years, till she was paid off in 1933, and scrapped in 1935. Sold for £1,800, ANZAC was sunk off Sydney on 7 May 1936 as target practice for RAN ships.

S Class

The other five S Class Destroyers – HMA Ships STALWART (1), SUCCESS, SWORDSMAN, TASMANIA and TATTOO were of 1,070 tons, 276ft in length, beam 26¾ft, draught 10½ft, with 3×4″ guns, 1x2pdr, pompoms and machine guns, 4×21″ torpedoes, speed 34 knots and complement of 90 officers and ratings.

For these ships, the majority of their service life was spent in port, and on the east coast, the only exception being TASMANIA, which visited New Guinea in 1924.

These S Class were famous ships, and over sixty more were built for the Royal Navy to replace WW I ships, and though many were scrapped between the wars, eleven still served in the Royal Navy during WW II.

The RAN’s five were built in the UK 1917/18, and commissioned into the RAN 1920. They paid off and went to Reserve in the late 1920s to 1930, and were all sold by 1937.

TATTOO was the last to pay off in 1933. On one of its last trips outside Sydney’s Heads, when passing the Matson Liner MARIPOSA, it signalled ‘Are you catching any fish’. Poor TATTOO! At least – they claimed – TATTOO never broke down.

V&W Class

Next, after service with the Royal Navy from 1918 to 1932, STUART transferred to the Royal Australian Navy in October 1933, along with four V & W Class destroyers (to replace the old S Class destroyers).

HMAS STUART (1) was a Scott Class Destroyer Leader, with displacement of 2,000 tons, length 332ft, beam 31¾ft, draught 12¼ft. Her armament (original) was 5×4.7″ guns, 1×3″ AA and small arms, and 6×21″ torpedoes. Speed 36½ knots and ship’s complement of 185. In her RAN commission, she was the Flotilla Leader, and up to 1939 served mainly in Australian waters, though being decommissioned for two short periods in that time.

With the declaration of war in 1939, STUART (Cmdr H.M.L. Waller, RAN), with the V & Ws HMA Ships VAMPIRE (1), VENDETTA (1), VOYAGER (1), and WATERHEN (1), sailed for the Mediterranean, where the Flotilla saw much action along the North African coast, with the British Fleet all over the Eastern Mediterranean, and with HMAS SYDNEY in action against the Italian Fleet at Calabria, through to the Battle of Matapan, then landings of troops on Greece and Crete, and later evacuating those troops after German occupation. STUART departed the Mediterranean August 22nd 1941, to return to Australia to commence a long and overdue refit, till April 1942. She then served in north eastern Australian waters till 1946, paying off 27th April 1946 and was scrapped in 1947.

Pages: Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4 Page 5 Page 6

Spakhia

March 31, 1983

ON A SMALL BAY on the south coast of Crete is a village or township called Spakhia. Landward approaches are steep-to and the harbour has – or had – no facilities worth mentioning. So it appeared to be an unimpressive place to embark retreating troops, but in May 1941 our choices were very limited.

‘Old Sweats’ will remember we used to call this the ‘bow and arrow’ stage of the war, when the Hun had everything that opened and shut, and we had bows and arrows – or so it seemed.

One day HMA Ships Napier and Nizam and two other destroyers proceeded to Spakhia, arrived after dark, and embarked our assigned quotas of troops as best we could. On this occasion we had to use our own boats. Each destroyer had a 27′ whaler and a 25′ motor cutter. The soldiery were in fairly poor condition, a lot being ‘walking wounded’ and many of that category only just able to walk.

About half way through this operation an aircraft droned overhead and a parachute flare burst above us, lighting up our activity with exasperating efficiency.

So we expected ructions – but none occurred! We finished our loading and had an uneventful run back to Alexandria. And this was good practice for our next effort.

On this occasion I was able to go aft to my cabin on the way back, and so observed a tough little piece of ‘field’ surgery. Slung to the deckhead was a yardarm group, lighting up a circle of deck space and foiling the deckhouse door blackout switches. In the circle of light a soldier lay on his stomach. Alongside him, our little Rocky doctor, Spud Murphy, was on his knees tending a nasty wound in the man’s back. The wound was full of maggots and Spud assured us that had they not been there the last day or so, the man would have been much sicker. Our MO treated the wound, gave the patient a liberal dose of Medical Comforts brandy, and all was well.

A few days later Napier, Nizam and two of Louis Mountbatten’s orphans set out for Spakhia again. But the two orphans (ex 5th Flotilla) had to be sent back at different times due to ‘delay action’ machinery defects caused by near miss bombing a day or two previously. We (in Napier) thought this a bit strange, but had a sharp lesson in such things within 24 hours.

We made Spakhia without further incident. Again it was a fine clear dark night – good weather for clandestine work. And this time the Army had available a few LCIs – flat bottomed ramp bowed powered craft – which greatly facilitated our loading.

And the troops were in generally better fettle. They were also of surprising variety – practically all sections of the British, Australian and NZ forces, including quite a few Maoris. But not all our guests were soldiers. We embarked also a Czechoslovak family of father, mother, teenage boy and girl and red setter dog! As well we received seven Chinese seamen and five (5) assorted chaplains!!

Having only two destroyers instead of four obliged us to lift about 500 men each ship. With a ship’s company of about 230, that made us a bit crowded, and apt to get in each other’s way – which we did, later on.

Having embarked our double quotas in the allowed time, we weighed anchor and set course and speed (about 25 knots) for Alexandria, the while settling down as best we could. And the galley staff bent heart and mind and hand to the production of a hot meal for all hands before arrival. In this they succeeded, despite interruptions, and the Chief Cook was among those decorated some months later.

Among our ‘walking wounded’ this time was a young officer of the Royal Tank Corps with a nasty twisted sliver of steel from his tank forced up through the arch of his foot. Someone had lashed a short bent length of gum tree wood from heel to ball so he could walk! As soon as he could get round to it, Spud Murphy had this chap laid out on my bunk, pressed the Captain’s Secretary into service as anaesthetist, and extracted the offending metal. He then dressed the wound, administered a suitable amount of MC brandy, and left the brave Tanker feeling at peace with the world and quite marvellous.

And then the JU88s came!

My cabin was just under ‘X’ guns – twin 4.7 inch. These weapons normally fired on non-destructive elevations and bearings from bow round to quarter, but when trying to repel hostile aircraft they were apt to loose off in all directions. This happened now, and my cabin water bottle rack fell off the bulkhead and just missed the patient’s newly repaired foot. Then the book rack sprang off and nearly fell on his head. Loose gear in the cabin went in all directions, flakes of corkdust fell from the deckhead, and the chap’s sense of peace and well-being was quite savagely disturbed.

I had been up on the Bridge, talking to D7, and was going aft along the main deck towards the engine-room hatchways when the bombs came whistling down and Napier began standing on her beam ends dodging them. There is quite a knack in evading aircraft bombs, and fortunately our two captains had it, so neither of us was hit, but -.

The soldiers on deck lay down, to increase protection from underwater bomb splinters (ship’s side and ship’s deck). And I just could not avoid treading on some of them as I had to get below. But they didn’t seem to mind!

By the time I made the engine-room, we were minus the steam of one boiler (out of two). It was this way:

A destroyer at speed suffering near-miss bombs is a bit like a frightened horse at a rodeo. The rapid helm movements and nearby explosions make her whip and shudder – it’s a weird feeling underfoot. And it’s bad for cast iron, of which HM ships in those days had plenty. The foot of the working oil fuel pump in the after boiler room broke away from the barrel, and oil fuel was sprayed all over the furnace front of the boiler.

We missed an explosion and general fire in that boiler room by the skin of our teeth – and the promptness of the SPO in charge (actually a leading stoker doing higher duties due to shortage of complement). He shut down and abandoned the boiler room in correct order (juniors first).

Both main engines were still running, and our speed on one boiler was about 24 knots, but there was a nasty crack diagonally across the forward foot of the port main engine. That machine, ever since commissioning, had a trying habit of vibrating at certain speeds ahead and astern. So I got the Damage Control Party to ‘shore’ the damaged casting down from the strength beams overhead, using 4×4 timber shores and wedges kept at certain locations, primarily for use on WT bulkheads. It looked a bit daft, but I was happier when they finished.

One of our main turbo-generators was ‘tripped’ off the board and a few minutes elapsed before it could be ‘kicked’ on again. Meanwhile the forward boiler room watchkeepers ‘slammed on’ the two small diesel generators. Of more importance and alarm was a few minutes failure of some sections of the Oldham-Hewer automatic emergency lantern system. This comprised torch-like lanterns slung overhead in working spaces, which switched themselves on when main power supply failed. Quite a help when they worked – which they usually did.

Abaft the engine-room was the gear room, containing the main turbine reduction gears and lubricating oil drain tanks – or ‘sump tanks’ if you like. Oil level was indicated port and starboard by floatoperated pointers in a pair of stand pipes, central and close together, within reach of a pair of valves for controlling the oil levels. All too easy given light, but in pitch darkness in a ship behaving abominably – ! Well, the stoker watchkeeper ‘kept his cool’, braced himself against the ship’s antics, ‘felt’ the oil levels at the stand-pipes and worked the valves as necessary, until the CERA arrived with a torch closely followed by main lighting restoration. That was a good effort – we did not require main engine oil failure just then.

A mildly humorous angle of the short blackout occurred at the After Magazine. Here, the sailors grabbed the first bodies they saw for Ammunition Supply Party. Thus for a while we were firing up star shell at our attackers – STAR SHELL! in the forenoon of a bright Mediterranean Spring day. They must have thought we were barmy.

The attack ended as suddenly as it began, and we soldiered along on our remaining boiler, sorting ourselves out.

About 9.30, having decided ‘everything was bearing an even strain’, I went aft and joined the umpteenth shift of eaters in the wardroom for breakfast.

But the propeller throb suddenly died away and as I rushed back to the engineroom, the boiler ‘blew off’, i.e. lifted its safety valve.

Arrived in the engine-room (without having to tread on prone Maoris this time), I found the port main circulating pump had stopped – without warning and for no apparent reason. The watchkeepers, seeing the port condenser temperature rising, had shut down both engines.

The function of the main circulators was to draw sea water in through the ship’s bottom and discharge it through the main condenser tube nests, where it condensed exhaust steam back to boiler feed water and maintained precious vacuum, and overboard.

And this ‘gremlin’ type stoppage of a main circulator after near misses was exactly what happened in Jackal the day before, obliging us to send her back.

Fortunately I remembered a quiff used by our ship-builders during acceptance trials in the Firth of Clyde the previous December.

The cooling water inlet and discharge pipes – about 2 feet diam. in a destroyer – are built into the ship’s bottom at a very acute angle. So, when the ship gets a bit of headway on, water is ‘sluiced’ in through the condensers, reducing the effort needed by the circulators. Our contractors used to shut the circulators nearly right off when steadied on a speed run, thus saving a skerrick of fuel and improving their consumption figures. Canny Scots!

Sea temperature in the Mediterranean in May is somewhat higher than that in the Firth of Clyde in December but needs must when the devil drives. So, while my merry (?) men attacked the recalcitrant circulator with spanners, hammers, grease and bad language, I gently opened the starboard ahead throttle and ran that engine up to the revs. for about 15 knots, to see if the ‘sluicing’ effect would occur.

And glory be, it did! The port condenser temperature came down and its vacuum rose, so we gave the port engine a few pounds of steam – and she took it. We then urged the starboard engine to further effort and followed with the port to the extent that she could ‘take it’. A few more steps like this had the starboard engine steaming at about 22 knots and ‘carrying’ the port engine circulator-wise, at about 16 knots.

I phoned these figures up to Steve Arliss, then went up on the Bridge to see him.

He had hoisted speed flags for 19 knots and ordered Nizam to take station ahead of us, on a zigzag course and using her Asdic set.

I apologised for the boiler blow-off, told him briefly of the fun and games in the engine-room and assured him we would get to Alex. even if we had to sail there, using the Forecastle and Waist awnings as sails!

Glad was he to have his engines running at any speed, for we were still in unhealthy waters.

No further shennanikins occurred and we made Alexandria that afternoon. (I can’t remember exactly when – all this was 40 years ago). At a suitable distance Nizam was sent ahead to report by signal lamp, numbers, damage and requirements including two tugs for Napier with her dicey port engine.

These two vessels took us over at the breakwater, and as we proceeded up Alex. Harbour, every ship we passed cheered us like billy-oh! And that was good for our morale.

NOTES AND GLOSSARY

I was Engineer Officer of HMAS Napier, and Staff Engineer to D7. As such, I could go anywhere and do anything, more or less.

Deckhead: In a ship, what you stand on is a deck, and the underside of the next deck above you is the deckhead – one may not call this the ceiling, because a ship’s ceiling is down near the keel!

Yardarm Group – An electric light cluster to increase light for temporary or emergency work.

Rocky – RANR and RANVR officers we called ‘Rockies’. But RANR (S) – Merchant Service types called up – we called ‘Chain Gang’ because of their double wavy stripes. But nowadays all Reservists wear the same ‘straight stripes’ as the Permanents with an ‘R’ in the curl.

My cabin guest of the Royal Tank Corps I never saw, these details were given to me by Captain’s Secretary, a Canadian-born RN fellow called Gillespie. But he (the Tanker) left me a souvenir pair of Zeiss binoculars – now in the possession of my grandson.

D7 – The Captain (D), 7th Destroyer Flotilla – Captain Stephen H.T. Arliss, RN.

Although they were RAN ships, Napier, Nizam, Nestor, Norman and Nepal had sprinklings of RN personnel for convenience of drafting. In Napier the Captain, Navigator, Captain’s Secretary, Coxswain, Chief Yeoman of Signals, Flotilla Shipwright and one of the SPOs were RN. The ratings were sad at losing their rum ration, but soon got over it. Talking of which, the RN abandoned the rum ration a few years ago – ‘change and decay is all around I see.’

SPO – Stoker Petty Officer. Now called Petty Officer Engineering Mechanic – a descriptive but cumbersome tally.

CERA – Chief Engine-room Artificer.

ASDIC – The letters stand for Allied Submarine Detection Investigation Committee – a body set up during the First World War to find an answer to the submarine warfare which nearly won that war for Germany. A sort of underwater Radar, it is now called Sonar.

In those days (1941) the critical target speed at which submarine attack became difficult was 18 knots.

There is no danger in blowing off a boiler, as the exhaust pipes are led up at safe angles. But in a destroyer they are level with the Bridge and only a few feet abaft it. And the crashing roar of escaping steam just behind one’s ears is bad for the nerves of Bridge personnel – more so if recently bombed.

Sailing a destroyer? Somewhere, sometime a British light cruiser broken down was sailed several miles using her Forecastle and Quarterdeck awnings as sails. But in a destroyer, with only one decent mast and one good awning, it would be even more dicey.

Destroyer flotilla
are now called Destroyer Squadrons.

Main turbine fleet are now made of cast steel instead of cast iron, and held down by ‘shock absorber’ type fastenings of quite remarkable efficiency.

Captain A.S. Rosenthal DSO and Bar, OBE, RAN

December 31, 1975

ALVORD SYDNEY ROSENTHAL was born in Sydney on 16th January 1901. He came from a distinguished military family, being the younger son of Major-General Sir Charles Rosenthal, a Divisional Commander in France in World War

Educated at The King’s School, Parramatta, young Rosenthal entered the Royal Australian Naval College at Jervis Bay in January 1915 as a Cadet-Midshipman in the Third Entry. The 1915 Entry consisted of 31 cadets, several of whom were to distinguish themselves later, including Vice Admiral Sir Roy Dowling, and Commander Jefferson Walker (lost in Parramatta).

Commander Donald Clarke, also of the 1915 Entry, recently wrote: ‘I recall Rosenthal as a dominating personality in our group of cadets, he was popular, energetic and powerfully built‘. The First Entry had been in 1913, which had meant that Rosenthal’s elder brother had had to join the Royal Navy, rather than the Royal Australian Navy, in 1912. Around this pre-1914 period, several Australian brothers were split between the two navies, as the RAN was not inaugurated until 1911.

When Rosenthal joined the College in 1915, his father was serving at Gallipoli, and his elder brother was at sea with the RN as a midshipman.

After four years of intensive training, Rosenthal, known to his friends as ‘Rosy’, passed out of Jervis Bay in December 1918, and in January 1919 sailed for England in the Transport Marathon to gain seagoing training with the Royal Navy. Those cadets who had joined in 1913 and 1914 had been appointed to battleships of the Grand Fleet. Those of Rosenthal’s year missed the War, but were able to gain valuable experience in its aftermath. After six weeks at Whale Island Gunnery School in Portsmouth, the midshipmen were drafted to the Fleet. Rosenthal’s first ship was the battleship Ramillies, one of the five ships of the Royal Sovereign Class, completed in 1917.

When he joined Ramillies on 7th May 1919, the ship formed part of the guard on the German Fleet at Scapa Flow. He had missed the actual surrender of the German High Seas Fleet in November 1918, but both his father and his brother had witnessed the historic ceremony from the Australian cruiser Melbourne.

The scuttling of the German Fleet at Scapa Flow was the highlight of Rosenthal’s service in Ramillies, and made a profound impression on the young midshipman. A number of men from the scuttled ships were picked up by Ramillies and taken to Invergordon. The body of one captain who had been killed by his own crew was also taken onboard.

On 21st June 1919, the First Battle Squadron was at sea in the Pentland Firth for torpedo exercises. At 1220 the Flagship received a signal from the destroyer Wescott in Scapa Flow that the German battleship Frederick Der Grosse was sinking at her moorings. Ramillies, Revenge and Royal Sovereign arrived in time to see Seydlitz capsize and sink. It was a dismal end to a fleet that had fought so well.

After visits to various seaside resorts in January 1920, the First Battle Squadron made rendezvous off Plymouth with the Atlantic Fleet for the Spring Cruise, which was planned to cover northern Spain, Gibraltar, Las Palmas and Algiers, but for the First Battle Squadron the Cruise actually extended for more than a year. The midshipmen were to see the grim aftermath of war in the Middle East and to witness at close hand revolution, fire, famine, and wanton slaughter, before they returned to Devonport.

Rosenthal’s first taste of action took place when the First Battle Squadron was ordered to the Bosphorus and the Black Sea to protect Allied interests against the Turkish Nationalists, and also to protect the White Russian Army retreating from the Bolsheviks. On 16th March 1920 the British and Allied warships lay off Calata in the Bosphorus, and Allied troops marched in to occupy the town. Four thousand seamen and Marines were landed from the ships. Landings were also made at Trebizond on the southern coast of the Black Sea. Here all the Marines and four companies of seamen took a fort and blew up its guns.

The First Battle Squadron returned home in August 1920, and for the rest of that year they did the round of the Home Ports.

Pages: Page 1 Page 2 Page 3 Page 4
  • Go to page 1
  • Go to page 2
  • Go to page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Go to page 11
  • Go to Next Page »

Primary Sidebar

SUBSCRIBE

Sign up for our monthly e-newsletter.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Categories

Latest Podcasts

  • First Victory, Musical Composition by Petty Officer Musician Martyn Hancock
  • AE2 – Stoker’s Submarine, Musical Composition by Lieutenant Matthew Klohs RAN.
  • AE1 – The Ship without a Name, Musical Composition by Lieutenant Matthew Klohs RAN.
  • The Loss of HMAS Armidale by Dr Kevin Smith
  • D-Day commando on Sword Beach by Commander Jim Speed DSC, RAN

Links to other podcasts

Australian Naval History Podcasts
This podcast series examines Australia’s Naval history, featuring a variety of naval history experts from the Naval Studies Group and elsewhere.
Produced by the Naval Studies Group in conjunction with the Submarine Institute of Australia, the Australian Naval Institute, Naval Historical Society and the RAN Seapower Centre

Life on the Line Podcasts
Life on the Line tracks down Australian war veterans and records their stories.
These recordings can be accessed through Apple iTunes or for Android users, Stitcher.

Video Links

  • Australian War Memorial YouTube channel
  • Royal Australian Navy YouTube Channel
  • Research – We can help!
  • Naval Heritage Sites
  • Dockyard Heritage Tour
  • About us
  • Shop
  • Events
  • Members Area
  • Volunteer
  • Donate
  • Contact us

Facebook

  • Members Area
  • Privacy Policy
  • Log Out

Naval Historical Society of Australia Inc. Copyright © 2021